General Contracting
Gaps in Hardwood Floors in Winter: Normal or a Problem?
By Noah Spagnotti

Every year, once the furnace has been running for a few weeks, some homeowners notice thin dark lines opening up between their hardwood floorboards. It can look like the floor is coming apart. In most cases it isn't. Wood shrinks when the air dries out, and winter air inside a heated Omaha home gets very dry. This guide explains why seasonal gaps happen, how to tell a normal gap from a real problem, and what to do (and not do) about them.
TL;DR
Small gaps that show up in late fall and winter and close again in spring and summer are normal for solid wood floors.
The cause is low indoor humidity. Keeping your home around 30 to 50 percent relative humidity is the best way to reduce them.
Don't fill seasonal gaps. When the wood swells again, hard filler can crush the board edges.
Gaps that stay open through humid months, keep growing, or show up in one spot are worth having someone look at.
Watch for window condensation if you add humidity. On the coldest days you may need to stay toward the low end of the range.
Why wood floors gap in winter
Wood takes on and gives off moisture to match the air around it. The National Wood Flooring Association (NWFA) puts it simply: in humid environments wood gains moisture and can swell, and in dry environments it loses moisture and can shrink. When floors lose moisture, they can gap between boards or even split on the face of a board.
Winter is when that drying happens. Cold outdoor air holds little moisture, and heating it inside your home drops the relative humidity further. NWFA's Hardwood Floors magazine explains that nearly every wood floor will have some seasonal separation between boards during the fall and winter months, and that once the heat is turned off or humidity is added, most of those gaps disappear.
The USDA Forest Products Laboratory's Wood Handbook notes that flooring is usually dried to the moisture content expected in service so that shrinking and swelling stay small. Small is not zero, though. A floor will still move a little with the seasons, and that is by design.
Why some floors gap more than others
Two floors in the same neighborhood can behave very differently. According to the same Hardwood Floors article, a few things make a big difference:
Board width. Shrinkage is roughly proportional to width. An 8-inch plank will shrink about twice as much as a 4-inch plank of the same species and cut.
Species and cut. Different woods, and boards cut different ways from the log, move by different amounts.
Solid vs. engineered. Engineered wood flooring is more dimensionally stable, so it gaps less. It still reacts to dry air, but instead of gapping it can "dry cup," with the edges of each plank lifting slightly.
New construction. In a tight new home, moisture from concrete, drywall and other materials can soak into the flooring and subfloor. When the house finally dries out, often 6 to 12 months after move-in, the boards shrink and gaps can appear that may not fully close again.
So if your wide-plank floor shows bigger gaps than your neighbor's narrow strip floor, that alone doesn't mean anything is wrong.
Normal gaps vs. a real problem
The simplest test is time. NWFA says gaps and splits are considered normal if they appear and disappear during normal seasonal changes. If gaps are large or do not close during the more humid months, it's time to have a professional take a look.
Signs a gap is probably seasonal:
It showed up after the heat came on.
It runs between many boards across the room, not just one area.
It closed up last summer and came back this winter.
Signs it may be something else:
Gaps that stay open all year, or get wider every winter.
Gaps concentrated in one spot, like over a heat duct or near an exterior wall.
Boards that move, squeak or feel loose underfoot along with the gaps.
Cupping, buckling or staining, which point to moisture rather than dryness.
The Hardwood Floors article lists common causes of abnormal gaps, including structural movement or settlement, the wrong fasteners or fastening schedule, an inadequate subfloor, boards that weren't acclimated before installation, edge damage from a past moisture event, and a poorly insulated heating duct below the floor. Those need a real diagnosis, not just a humidifier. If your gaps come with squeaks, our guide to fixing squeaky floors covers how loose boards and subfloors are tracked down.
How to reduce winter gaps
Check your humidity first
Buy an inexpensive hygrometer and put it in the room with the wood floor. The EPA notes these meters are small, inexpensive instruments available at many hardware stores. Reading it for a few days tells you whether dry air is really the cause.
Aim for 30 to 50 percent
NWFA recommends keeping your home between 60 and 80 degrees Fahrenheit and between 30 and 50 percent humidity year-round, using a humidification system to get there in winter. That lines up with the EPA's general advice to keep indoor humidity ideally between 30 and 50 percent.
You can add moisture with a whole-house humidifier on your furnace or with portable units. If you use portable humidifiers, the EPA's tips for the use and care of home humidifiers are worth following: empty and refill the tank daily, use low-mineral water such as distilled water, clean the unit every third day, and don't humidify above 50 percent, since higher levels can encourage mold and dust mites.
Watch your windows
More humidity isn't always better in an Omaha winter. This Old House heating expert Richard Trethewey suggests ideal humidity somewhere between 30 and 40 percent, and warns that on the coldest days, too much humidity can cause condensation on cold window glass. If you see water on the inside of your windows, turn it down a bit. Our guide to window condensation inside explains what's normal and what isn't.
Should you fill the gaps?
For seasonal gaps, no. NWFA's guidance is that filler used when the floor is dry may permanently damage the flooring once the wood swells again. Some fillers are as hard as the wood and can crush the board edges, leaving uglier gaps than before. Your options are to live with the gaps until spring or add humidity so the boards swell back.
Some floors also have a gap built in on purpose as an internal expansion joint. Those shouldn't be filled either.
For gaps that stay open year-round, a repair can make sense once the cause is fixed and the floor has stabilized. According to the Hardwood Floors article, small gaps can be filled with a matching filler and the floor recoated, larger gaps may need thin wood slivers glued in, and sometimes individual boards need to be replaced. This Old House shows another approach for gaps in a wide-plank floor: pressing natural-fiber rope into the gap and staining it to blend in, which suits older, rustic floors.
Pulling up and replacing a gapped floor is rarely the answer. The Hardwood Floors article calls removal and replacement to fix gaps usually both unnecessary and self-defeating, since a floor that has settled into your home is more likely to stay stable than new boards.
Thinking about new floors?
If you're planning new flooring, gaps are one more thing to weigh. Narrower boards and engineered wood move less than wide solid planks. Whatever you choose, giving the material time to acclimate and keeping your home's humidity steady will do more for the floor than anything else.
Our perspective
Most winter floor gaps aren't a defect. They're a humidity reading you can see. Check the air before you worry about the floor, add moisture carefully, and give it until spring. If the gaps are still there when the windows are open in June, that's when it's worth finding out why.
Need help in Omaha?
Spagnotti Contracting installs and repairs flooring across the Omaha metro, including hardwood installation, hardwood refinishing and subfloor repair. You can read about our flooring service, see all of our services, or contact us with questions. Hardwood work is priced by custom proposal, because it depends on the species, the room and the condition of the subfloor.
FAQ
Are gaps in hardwood floors normal in winter?
Yes, for most solid wood floors. Small gaps that appear when the heat is on and close in spring and summer are a normal reaction to dry indoor air.
What humidity should I keep my house at for hardwood floors?
NWFA recommends 30 to 50 percent relative humidity and 60 to 80 degrees Fahrenheit year-round. On very cold days, stay toward the lower end if you see condensation on your windows.
Should I fill the gaps between my floorboards?
Not if they're seasonal. Filler can crush the board edges when the wood swells again. Only gaps that stay open year-round should be repaired, after the cause is fixed.
When should I call someone about floor gaps?
When gaps don't close in humid months, keep getting wider, are concentrated in one area, or come with loose boards, cupping or staining.
Dealing With Something Similar?
Every property is different, but if this sounds like what you’re seeing, we’re happy to take a look and help you figure out what’s actually going on.